why Linux MCE is superior to windows MCE
Linux MCE is superior to windows MCE
* Cost
* Cost
The number one reason for choosing Linux, people have reported building a Linux media center with $400 total cost. Top that! Of course if you have unlimited budget this is not an argument. On the other hand what can be defined as unlimited? With equal money you will always be capable of building more. That's why big movie studios use Linux.
* A whole house media system build with cheap diskless hardware
Have some old PC's laying around? You can use them as pxe bootable thin clients for your Linux MCE system, most cheap graphics cards support tv out for a while now. Make a pc pxe bootable over the network and use it as a media director. And you can have one master system serving media throughout the whole house.
* Integrated voice over IP and video over IP
As asterisk is integrated into LinuxMCE you get a full featured voip telephony system. This gives you limitless features which are normally only on very expensive telephony hardware.
Videocalls, videoconferencing, VOIP, and personal voicemailboxes for each member of your family are possible. The system can keep track of where you are in your home and route incoming calls to the nearest phone (or to your mobile phone when you're not at home).
* Home automation features
Linux MCE has home automation features which make it possible to control all kinds of things in your house trough mobile phones or internet connected computers. Check if the lights are out? turn up the heater before your going home if your visiting friends? It can all be done with one central server which is in the same time recording your favorite tv program.
* Home security
It's possible to connect many devices to your LinuxMCE which are capable of guarding your house and for instance stream video data to a off-site location. Recording what is happening at a security breach, so even if they burn down your house you can record and keep save evidence.
* Parental control
You can limit what is visible on the thin clients at the times you want, so your children wont have a signal when it's bedtime.
* No limits on tuners
LinuxMCE is not limited to 2 analog tuners and 2 digital tuners as is windows MCE. This is hackable in windows MCE, but standard it's limited.
In Vista outside the US it seems your limited to 2 tuners unless you install addons and to get support for the maximum of 8 tuners you need vista ultimate.
* Future proof
You can never count on windows to be future proof. When using Linux as the base for a media center you'll be sure of having a future proof system. If new technology comes up and new features can be added to your system, you have the most change of being able to mix the stuff you want to keep, with new things in Linux.
Windows is going to a new version every now and then, and new hardware wont be supported by your old windows while old hardware wont be supported by your new windows.
* Unlimited users logging in on the same time
The amount of users logged in and using the media center is limited by hardware and network capabilities alone. This is definitely not the case with windows media center. There's a hack to make windows mce 2005 run 3 simultaneous rdp sessions. But in Linux you are free to have as many users as you want.
This is just a short list, if anybody can come up with more benefits of Linux MCE, feel free to leave a comment. And correct me if you think I'm wrong. Comments will be reviewed and can take up to 10 hours before they get published.
(different time zone)
Popular content
Recent blog posts
- HP linux netbook
- Toshiba Android netbook
- android video terminal
- rugged android phone
- Linux PC Robot < 500$ DIY Linux robot
- Q7 Linux MID nice but missing most important feature
- BD remote for android available soon
- Intelligent Linux based scriptable network camera
- Edge the first foldable dual screen ebook reader/netbook
- iPed chinese for iPad
don't forget to vote if you find something useful!!
- Hm
43 weeks 4 days ago - What is it called?
44 weeks 1 day ago - i done everything . when i
47 weeks 1 day ago - 11. Be logged in with more
49 weeks 5 days ago - Additions to computer user
49 weeks 5 days ago - Source code Philips tv
49 weeks 6 days ago - philps 5604 source code
49 weeks 6 days ago - Getting a error ___Main__.PY error any ideas?
1 year 1 week ago - Meh....
1 year 3 weeks ago - not the smallest
1 year 3 weeks ago
Navigation
Arduino starter kit
nederlandse arduino tutorials

Smallest Linux PC, smaller
than an apple

Linux home automation

Electrical superbike
powered by Linux

Coolest Linux robot ever
transforming,camera,
remote control

Samsung tv Linux hack

Linux multimedia
dream machine

More cool stuff
like this solid gold macbook
at criticalcold.com
Tags
Best karma users
- mr-Z
- Ian_js
- dave-d
- gamer2k2
- links9
Categories



LinuxMCE
Anonymous 2 years 31 weeks 3 days 12 min ago
Hello,
I am one of the core LinuxMCE developers.
I understand some of you have issue with the way media is handled in LinuxMCE.
One of the things on my personal list is to refine the output of the media lists so that:
* TV shows are shown most recent first
* TV show series are collapsed
* clicking on collapsed TV series, shows the expanded series.
As far as critiques about the UI are concerned, We are always looking for designers who want to make a better UI. Replacing Pluto's original Basic skin is on our list, and we're approaching that item, but we're not there yet.
Do keep in mind, however, that the entire UI is completely customizable, way beyond the UI flexibility offered by other media center systems, as this was meant to be a replacement for Crestron and AMX.
0810 is just around the corner. We have an alpha release available, and we are gearing up for the beta, with tons of new features and UI fixes.
-Thom
LinuxMCE - generally unusable
Anonymous 2 years 44 weeks 6 days 18 hours ago
The concepts contained within LinuxMCE are brilliant and go way beyond anything available at the moment.
But - and this is a big one - it's largely unusable for the average end user.
If all you want to do is access your media content in an organised fashion then LinuxMCE is not for you.
I stuck at it for nearly a year, and bluntly gave up out of sheer frustration. I now use another popular freeware media centre app. It's nowhere near as fully featured as LMCE but anyone that walks into my living room can browse the media and pick something to watch or listen to without me having to explain how to find it.
At the most basic level, LMCE, even with filters etc., simply does not natively handle the show/season/episode and artist/album/track playback functionality in sensible fashion, unless you've been taught how to do it or read the forums to discover ways around it.
LinuxMCE is fantastic, and has all the clever tricks I want for a networked media system. Shame, then, that at the most basic level I can't view the media in the way that I want.
Check out the LMCE forums. There are almost religious-level wars about this there. I find it astonishing that the lead developers have poured so much effort into a MAME extension for LMCE when the most important aspect - usability - just isn't there. Don't try and tell them that it's not there, though - you'll get flamed.
Why is Windows MCE better than Linux:
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 1 day 18 hours ago
1. DRM support - Windows without DRM is like traffic without traffic accidents
2. Huge collection of software, in fact hundreds of thousands rock-solid apps, which some crazy Lunix fans and security experts around the world call malware, which is nonsence because these applications are most stable and persistant applications ever written.
Why is Windows MCE better than Linux
admin 2 years 50 weeks 1 day 8 hours ago
DRM support is a good thing?
I have a very different opinion about this.
You know sometimes I see DRM movies trying to access a remote server, just to compromise privacy.
and what about this:
"The use of DRM may also be a barrier to future historians, since technologies designed to permit data to be read only on particular machines, or with particular keys, or for certain periods, may well make future data recovery impossible"
But this is a completely different discussion.
Huge collection of software?
Yes indeed windows malware is the most stable and certainly the most persistent software ever written :-)
And furthermore stable apps on an instable os is the same as building a well build house on quicksand.
Windows over Linux
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 1 day 21 hours ago
I just want something I can load all my movies onto and watch them without flipping thru tons of disks. Why I'd ever need something to route phone calls for is beyond me, or my needs. And run my lights? WTF?
Simple rules. And unfortunately, Windows is simple...
Yeah Yeah Yeah its better in
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 2 days 5 hours ago
Yeah Yeah Yeah its better in every way....oh except the most important one - THE USER INTERFACE. It's far too complex and just frankly hideous. To be blunt it look like it was designed by someone who writes software. What Linux MCE needs now is a proper designer to give the interface a complete overhaul.
You got to be kidding me.
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 1 day 17 hours ago
You got to be kidding me. The Windows interface nicer than Linux. I don't know what Linux interface you looked at but you must need glasses. The Gnome interface with compiz and awn rocks. I'm an MCSE and support a Windoz enterprise of about 4000 computers including Win 7 betas. Nothing beats a good Linux WM for eye candy and usability.
please read it
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 30 min 25 sec ago
please read it again!!
I'm NOT talking about the Windows interface being better than the Linux/Gnome interface. THAT IS NOT what the article or my comment is about.
I'm talking about the Windows Media Center Edition interface being better than Linux Media Center Edition. Which it is. 100 times better.
If you don't know what Linux MCE is, here it is: http://wiki.linuxmce.org/index.php/Screenshots
What does this have to do with Gnome or Compiz?
You ask what Linux interface I looked at? Currently I'm looking at Ubuntu Intrepid on my desktop computer and openSUSE 11.1 on my laptop. Both have Compiz installed with the gorgeous Dust theme on both.
Before you start insulting people at least try to understand what they are talking about >-(
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
This comment was edited slightly for inappropriate language.
The meaning wasn't changed :-)
admin
Why Windows MCE is supperior to Linux MCE.
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 2 days 15 hours ago
Convincing enough, doesn't it?
and why Linux MCE is not superior to windows MCE
Anonymous 2 years 50 weeks 2 days 17 hours ago
The points above are very valid but unfortunately until support for IR remote controls is getting better (LIRC is everything but perfect). Windows MCE will always be better.